My name is Taylor Smith. I am a third-year print journalism at the University of South Carolina free-lance writer for The State newspaper here in Columbia. As president of SPJ here on campus, I have helped organize a members meeting this month, which will examine the ethical issues of NBC Dateline's "To catch a predator" shows. I am not sure if you have seen the shows but apparently since 2004, NBC has aired shows that feature a an on-line predator watchdog group called "Perverted Justice," who poses as a young lady on-line that is trying to meet a much older man to meet her at her home. After agreeing to meet at her (the young actress's) home, the girl meets the man, who is almost always a registered sex offender and abruptly leaves the room. This is where the NBC reporter enters the room and grills the man about why he is at the teenage girl's home and what he expected from the rendezvous. Shortly after the exchange, police enter the room and arrest the man.
According the to Nielsen ratings, the "Catch" shows have performed better than any other show in the time block they air, which is why NBC has made the shows a permanent fixture on Dateline programming. I realize this is a lot to swallow if you have not seen what I am talking about, but the NBC Dateline Website and a portion of an episode we will likely use at our meeting. Obviously the ethical questions arise: 1) What does "ambush journalism" do for the media's role as a watchdog over police, when they are cooperating so closely and 2) What do episodes like this do for the presumption of innocence of the accused? I'm sure I have missed an ethical qualm or two, so if you care to weigh in that would be appreciated, but my main question is: What is SPJ's stance on this new breed of journalism?
First off, I should disclose that a couple of years ago my newsroom did a similar project to what Dateline is doing and I helped supervise. The entire thing made me anxious because I knew many of the ethical pitfalls inherent in doing this. We did our best to navigate our way through what is both a legal and ethical maze, and I think we did so fairly well. I'm sure there are other journalists who would say we should not have undertaken the project in the first place, but that wasn't my decision to make.
In our case, we knew that similar projects had been undertaken in Kansas City, Philadelphia and, I think, Detroit if memory serves. In a couple of those cities, the outrage was directed at the broadcasters rather than the sex offenders. The stations had rented homes to lure the would-be predators. People who lived near the homes felt the stations may have endangered the community by luring the sex offenders. In one case, a church was nearby and called on authorities to prosecute the station. In another case, authorities said the project had the potential to undermine active investigations or to drive potential predators underground before authorities could deal with them.
We were sensitive to all of this and more. I've always tried to follow the SPJ Code of Ethics, even while running a very aggressive investigative unit. One relevant part of the code to this project is this:
Avoid undercover or other surreptitious methods of gathering information except when traditional open methods will not yield information vital to the public. Use of such methods should be explained as part of the story.
At the time, the use of chat rooms by sexual predators to locate their victims was a relatively new topic. One that could be considered to be of vital public importance because it could help inform parents about the dangers and allow them to take steps to protect their children. We decided to work with PervertedJustice.com, but in a limited way to try and get the story. They agreed to do what they usually do in terms of luring predators, but in this case, the purported young girl would be from the Twin Cities. We also decided to arrange for the meetings to be in a public place rather than a private home. PJ.com also agreed not to post their chat until we had time to do additional research and reporting. In this way we would only be slightly altering what PJ.com was going to do anyway rather than arranging an elaborate "sting" and also risk the criticism of bringing predators into a neighborhood. We could spend some more time trying to figure out who these potential predators actually are rather than ambushing them with cameras rolling.
After we had recorded PJ.com's chat with the predators, we did our best to determine if these people were real. We located three. One actually came to what he thought would be a meeting with a young girl at a public mall. Another turned out to be doing his sexual chat while he was at his job as an FAA controller. We shared some of our findings with the Metro Sexual Crimes Task Force to get their reaction. The material about the flight controller caused the local authorities to get a search warrant and question the man. He was taken into custody and charged with a felony. He was later found guilty and sent to prison.
All of this is background for you to understand that my take on these kind of stories might not be as "pure" from an ethical standpoint as others. We did our best to expose what we thought was a very real public safety issue in a powerful way while trying to not too closely align ourselves with either an advocacy group or public authorities. At the same time, we were mindful of the fact that once we knew of potential predators we could also be criticized for failing to do something that would reduce the risk to society.
I believe Dateline has taken a less thoughtful and more problematic approach. To begin with, the problem that is being exposed is no longer new. Even we were not pioneering when we did our stories, but at least those stories hadn't yet been done in our market. Now they've been done to the point of being a cliché. They may be great television, but it's growing hard to argue that they are news and therefore harder to argue the information is "vital to the public."
In addition, published reports indicate Dateline is now paying Perverted Justice for its services. Perhaps the deal has some sort of insulation to reduce all of the potential and actual conflicts of interest inherent in this, but if so, I don't know what those safeguards may be. Most would agree with the goals of getting sexual predators off the street, but many do object to PJ.com's methods. Dateline is now aligned with the methods through not only a news, but also a financial arrangement.
The deal gets even stickier in those instances where local authorities have "deputized" some of the PJ.com personnel. Dateline finds itself in a financial arrangement with people who are working directly with law enforcement for the apprehension and prosecution of individuals who are caught in a sting that is orchestrated by Dateline, PJ.com and local authorities. As these individuals go to trial, I don't see how Dateline can be anything other than an active part of the prosecution. It is a little late to be asserting they will "Act Independently."
In the end, I find myself questioning whether this program is actually a news program or a regularly scheduled entertainment program that has some of the trappings of news, but doesn't operate under the usual standards.
Sincerely,
Gary Hill
Chairman SPJ Ethics Committee
For more information about SPJs Code of Ethics, write to ethics@spj.org.
Ethics Committee This committee's purpose is to encourage the use of the Society's
Code of Ethics, which promotes the highest professional standards for journalists
of all disciplines. Public concerns are often answered by this committee. It
also acts as a spotter for reporting trends in the nation, accumulating case
studies of jobs well done under trying circumstances.
Ethics Committee Andy Schotz, chair
Hagerstown, Md. E-mail Bio (click to expand)
Andy Schotz is a reporter for The Herald-Mail, a daily newspaper in Hagerstown, Md. He has covered a variety of beats, including city hall and police and courts. He has sometimes filled in as city editor. He covered the Maryland statehouse during the 2007 and 2008 sessions. When he joined the paper in 2000, he was the one person in the one-person Berkeley County, W.Va., bureau.
Schotz is president of SPJs Washington, D.C., Pro chapter and has helped the Maryland-Delaware-D.C. Press Association with some projects. A Long Island native, he has a bachelors degree from the University at Albany in upstate New York. He previously worked for eight years at The Altamont Enterprise, a weekly paper outside Albany, as a reporter and, for part of that time, an editor.
Fred Brown, vice chair
2862 S. Oakland Ct.
Aurora, Colo., 80014
303/829-4647 E-mail Bio (click to expand)
Fred Brown is a former national president of SPJ (1997-98) and is very active on its ethics committee. He writes a column on ethics for Quill magazine and served on the committee that wrote the Societys 1996 code of ethics.
Brown officially retired from The Denver Post in early 2002, but continues to write a Sunday editorial page column for the newspaper. He also does analysis for Denvers NBC television station, teaches communication ethics at the University of Denver, and is a principal in Hartman & Brown, LLP, a media training and consulting firm. He has won several awards for writing and community service, including a Sigma Delta Chi Award for editorial writing in 1988. He is an Honor Alumnus of Colorado State University, a member of the Denver Press Club Hall of Fame, and serves on the boards of directors of Colorado Public Radio, the Colorado Freedom of Information Council and the Sigma Delta Chi Foundation.
SPJ Ethics Committee Members
Robert Buckman
337/482-5221 E-mail Bio (click to expand)
Robert Buckman, Ph.D., is an associate professor of communication at the University of Louisiana at Lafayette, where he has been on the faculty since 1989. He is head of the print journalism sequence and is faculty adviser for the SPJ chapter. His specialties include ethics, media-military relations and Latin American media, especially press freedom issues, and he has been a regular contributor to Quill on these topics. He is also a freelance journalist, writing for various newspapers and magazines on Latin American politics and on Louisiana politics and culture. He has been on the SPJ Ethics Committee since 1996, when he participated in revising the Code of Ethics.
Buckman earned a B.A. in journalism and political science from Texas Christian University in 1970, his M.A. in political science from TCU in 1972 and his Ph.D. from the University of Texas at Austin in 1986. He was a reporter for the Fort Worth Press from 1972 to 74, an editor with the U.S. Foreign Broadcast Information Service from 1974 to 80 and the Texas capitol correspondent for the Fort Worth News-Tribune from 1980 to 86. He was on the faculty of Loyola University in New Orleans from 1986 to 89. He served a Fulbright Fellowship in Chile in 1991.He was president of the Southeast Journalism Conference in 1998 and 99.
Casey Bukro
847/869-4193 E-mail Bio (click to expand)
Casey Bukro retired in 2007 as an overnight editor after 45 years at the Chicago Tribune, much of that time as an environment writer.
Before becoming an editor in 2000, he was an environment writer since 1967 and was the first reporter to hold that title on a major American newspaper. He pioneered environment and natural resource reporting in America.
Bukro previously served as SPJ's national ethics chair and regional director for SPJ's region 5. He participated in writing SPJ's Code of Ethics and was awarded the Wells Key in 1983. He co-founded the Ethics AdviceLine for Journalists and is the Chicago Headline Club's ethics chair.
Bukro was born and grew up in Chicago and holds bachelor's and master's degrees from the Medill School of Journalism at Northwestern University.
Jerry Dunklee
203/392-5801 E-mail Bio (click to expand)
Jerry Dunklee is a journalism professor at Southern Connecticut State University. He has four decades of experience as a broadcaster and teacher. He has worked as a news reporter, news director, program director and talk show host on radio, TV and cable in New Haven, New York and Boston. Dunklee has been published in the New York Times, Hartford Courant, New Haven Register, The Communicator and Quill. Dunklee is a member of the board of directors and a past president of the Connecticut Pro chapter of SPJ. He conducts ethics seminars and writing workshops for professional journalists.
Mike Farrell E-mail Bio (click to expand)
Mike Farrell serves as director of the Scripps Howard First Amendment Center at the University of Kentucky and as an assistant professor in the School of Journalism and Telecommunications. He began teaching as an adjunct in 1980 at Northern Kentucky University, continued as a graduate teaching assistant at UK in 1996, and has been a full-time faculty member there since 2000. He won the college teaching award in 2006.
He teaches reporting, editing, media law, media ethics, covering religion news and column writing.
He was a reporter, city editor and managing editor during a 20-year career at The Kentucky Post.
A native of Northern Kentucky, he earned his undergraduate degree at Moody Bible Institute, Chicago. He earned his master's and doctoral degrees at UK, where he focused on media law. He is a member of the Bluegrass Chapter and co-adviser of the UK student chapter of SPJ.
Irwin Gratz
207/874-6570 E-mail Bio (click to expand)
Irwin Gratz has been in radio news for nearly 30 years. He worked as a reporter, anchor and News Director for the number-one rated commercial station in Portland, Maine before going to work for public radio in 1992 as local anchor of Morning Edition.
A native of New York City, Irwin holds a Masters Degree in journalism from New York University. He has taught a college course on media ethics and has been a guest lecturer on journalism ethics and broadcast news writing.
Irwin has been a member of the Society of Professional Journalists since 1983 and has held positions as a state chapter president, a member of its national board and was the Societys national President in 2004 and 2005.
Irwin lives outside of Portland, Maine with his wife and young son.
Liz Hansen
859/608-7681 E-mail Bio (click to expand)
Elizabeth K. Hansen is a professor in the Department of Communication at Eastern Kentucky University where she has taught since 1987. She teaches Community Journalism, Media Ethics, Writing and Reporting News, Writing and Selling Nonfiction, Media Law, Public Affairs Reporting and Feature Writing.
Hansen holds a bachelors degree in journalism from the University of Arkansas at Fayetteville, a masters degree in journalism and mass communication from Iowa State University, and a Ph.D. in communication with emphases in mass media law and ethics from the University of Kentucky.
Hansen worked as a reporter for The Springdale News and the Arkansas Democrat in Arkansas and the State-Times in Baton Rouge, Louisiana. She also is a freelance writer whose work has been published in newspapers and magazines in Mississippi, Kentucky and elsewhere. Before joining the faculty at Eastern, she taught at Iowa State University, the University of Southern Mississippi and the University of Kentucky.
Hansen, who has been a member of SPJ for 30 years, is immediate past president of the Bluegrass Chapter of the Society of Professional Journalists and advises the Eastern Kentucky University SPJ chapter. She serves on the steering committee for the Institute for Rural Journalism and Community Issues, a multi-state, multi-institution program headquartered at the University of Kentucky. She is also a member of the Association for Education in Journalism and Mass Communication and the Association for Practical and Professional Ethics. She received the 2004 Russ Metz Most Valuable Member Award from the Kentucky Press Association for her work on a statewide public records audit.
Jane Kirtley
612/625-9038 E-mail Bio (click to expand)
Jane E. Kirtley has been the Silha Professor of Media Ethics and Law at the School of Journalism and Mass Communication at the University of Minnesota since August 1999. Prior to that, she was Executive Director of The Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press in Arlington, Virginia, for 14 years.
She was appointed Director of The Silha Center for the Study of Media Ethics and Law in May 2000, and was named to the affiliated faculty of the University of Minnesota Law School in March 2001. During the Spring 2004 semester, she was a Distinguished Visiting Professor of Law at Suffolk University Law School in Boston, Massachusetts.
Kirtley speaks frequently on First Amendment and freedom of information issues, both in the United States and abroad. She also writes the First Amendment Watch column for American Journalism Review.
Prof. Kirtley received her J.D. degree from Vanderbilt University School of Law in 1979. She holds bachelors and masters of journalism degrees from Northwestern Universitys Medill School of Journalism.
Paul LaRocque E-mail Bio (click to expand)
Paul R. LaRocque has been an advocate of journalism ethics for many years as a newspaper editor and as a journalism educator. He is a free-lance writing coach and author, and he has taught journalism at Texas universities.
LaRocque was a member and chair of the Associated Press Managing Editors Professional Standards Committee, which later became the Ethics Committee. He and journalism education colleagues at Texas Christian University researched and published pioneer studies on media treatment of crime victims. TCU presented LaRocque the 1995 Ethics in Journalism Award in recognition of his work in that field.
He was born in Worcester, Mass., and received a bachelors degree in journalism from Michigan State University and a masters degree in journalism from the University of North Texas. He and his wife, Paula, and toy poodle, Pompidou, live in Arlington, Texas.
LaRocque retired as student publications director at Texas Christian University, where he also taught reporting. He taught writing and other journalism courses at Southern Methodist University, the University of North Texas, and Grayson County College. He tutors media and business personnel in writing and does writing seminars and workshops for organizations and companies. He was the summer writing coach and intern program coordinator for the Omaha World-Herald for seven years, and also coached writers and editors at the Arlington Morning News.
LaRocque began his newspaper career as a copy clerk for the Worcester (Mass.) Telegram and Gazette. He was a library assistant for the Worcester newspaper before going on active duty with the Marine Corps Reserve. He was a sports writer for the Parris Island, S.C., Marine Recruit Depot base newspaper and a sports publicist for Marine information services.
He has been a reporter and copy editor for the Lansing (Mich.) State Journal; reporter and state editor for The Milwaukee Journal; executive editor for the San Mateo (Calif.) Times; managing editor of the Battle Creek (Mich.) Enquirer and News; editor of the Bryan-College Station (Texas) Eagle; and editorial page editor of the Fort Worth Star-Telegram. . And he has written book reviews for The Dallas Morning News and the Fort Worth Star-Telegram.
LaRocque is the author of The Concise Guide to Copy Editing: Preparing Written Work for Readers and Heads You Win: An Easy Guide to Better Headline and Caption Writing, both published by Marion Street Press.
He has been a member of the Society of Professional Journalists since 1958 and he served on the SPJ national board of directors from 1989 to 1991. LaRocque is vice president for programs of the Fort Worth SPJ chapter. He has been a director of the Freedom of Information Foundation of Texas, a national board member of the Associated Press Managing Editors, and a member of the National Conference of Editorial Writers.
Sara Stone E-mail Bio (click to expand)
Dr. Sara Stone, professor of journalism at Baylor University, teaches courses in media law and ethics and reporting and is the director of undergraduate studies for the journalism department at Baylor.
She served on a nationwide Task Force on the Ethics of the Media Coverage of the Mount Carmel standoff sponsored by the Society of Professional Journalists. She was national vice president for campus chapter affairs for the Society of Professional Journalists from 1988 to 1994. She is the SPJ student chapter adviser at Baylor.
Stone has professional journalistic experience in both print and broadcast. After graduating from the University of New Mexico in 1970 she joined the staff of the Amarillo Globe-News where she served as a reporter, copy editor, night news editor and assistant night city editor over the next four-and-a-half years. She obtained a masters degree in mass communications at Texas Tech University and taught in the journalism department at West Texas State University (now West Texas A&M) from 1974 to 1980. During the summers from 1976 through 1980 she worked as a reporter and weekend co-anchor for television station KVII, the ABC affiliate in Amarillo.
From 1980 to 1982, Stone attended the University of Tennessee where she earned a Ph.D. in communications. While a doctoral student, she worked part-time as a copy editor for the Knoxville News-Sentinel. She was named an outstanding doctoral student in the College of Communications at Tennessee, where she was a Bickel Fellow.
She has been on the faculty of the Baylor University journalism department since the fall of 1982. She has attended journalism educator workshops put on by both the American Press Institute and by the Poynter Institute. In 1987, she also was named the Outstanding Society of Professional Journalists Campus Chapter Adviser in the United States.
Peter Sussman
510/845-1311 E-mail Bio (click to expand)
Peter Y. Sussman is an independent journalist and author who spent 29 years in various editing positions at the San Francisco Chronicle. He has received numerous national and local journalism and First Amendment awards, many of them for his pioneering advocacy for media access to prisoners and his defense of Dannie M. Martin, a federal prisoner who was punished for an article he wrote that Sussman published in The Chronicle.
He is the co-author with Martin of Committing Journalism: The Prison Writings of Red Hog (W.W. Norton, 1993) and the editor of Decca: The Letters of Jessica Mitford (Knopf and Weidenfeld & Nicolson, 2006).
Sussman, a longtime member of SPJ's Ethics Committee, has also served as California Sunshine chair and two terms as president of the Northern California professional chapter. Among his national awards from SPJ are the Freedom of Information Award (1990), the Howard S. Dubin Outstanding Professional Chapter Member Award (1997) and the Wells Memorial Key, the Society's highest honor for an individual member (1999). In bestowing the Wells Key, the Society cited his “instrumental” role in writing SPJ's current Code of Ethics and his advocacy of press freedoms and journalism diversity, in both hiring and coverage.
Beginning in 2002, Sussman wrote and lectured widely on wartime journalism ethics, based on specific ethical conflicts during the "war on terror" and the Afghan and Iraqi invasions. He conducted a number of workshops to reconsider journalists’ wartime ethical obligations. One product of those workshops was a proposed set of guidelines to help resolve ethical conflicts in wartime.
Adrian Uribarri
786/514-5758 E-mail Bio (click to expand)
Adrian G. Uribarri is a staff writer at the Orlando Sentinel. Previously, he was a reporting trainee at the Los Angeles Times. He joined the Sentinel in June 2007, two years after he worked there as a Dow Jones Newspaper Fund business-reporting intern. During the summer of 2006, he was a DJNF copy-editing intern at the San Francisco Chronicle's business desk.
He has been a member of the Society of Professional Journalists since 2005, when he was elected president of the University of Florida chapter and campus representative on SPJ's board of directors. He joined the society's ethics committee in 2006. He was one of 10 SPJ members to travel to Taiwan in 2008 as part of the society's working-journalists delegation to the country.
He earned bachelor's degrees in journalism and political science from the University of Florida and has attended reporting and editing residencies at New York University and the University of Texas at Austin. He also is a member of the National Association of Hispanic Journalists and was a panelist at the 2006 convention of the Association for Education in Journalism and Mass Communication. He lives in Mount Dora, Fla.
Nerissa Young E-mail Bio (click to expand)
Nerissa Young is a recovering print journalist employed as assistant professor of print journalism at the W. Page Pitt School of Journalism and Mass Communications at Marshall University in Huntington, W.Va. Before that, she taught three years in the Department of Mass Communications at Shepherd University in Shepherdstown, W.Va., and in the journalism school at Oklahoma State University in Stillwater. Young has nearly 20 years of media experience that includes radio, newspapers, freelance and journalism education. A native West Virginian, she received her bachelors degree in secondary education from Concord College and her masters degree in journalism from Marshall University. She has been a member of SPJs national ethics committee since 1995 and spent seven years as chairwoman of SPJs national Project Watchdog committee. Young writes a weekly column, The Back Porch, about whatever tickles her momentary fancy for her former employer, The (Beckley, W.Va.) Register-Herald. At Marshall, she teaches news writing and reporting and advises the campus newspaper, The Parthenon.
Society of Professional Journalists
Eugene S. Pulliam National Journalism Center, 3909 N. Meridian St., Indianapolis, IN 46208
317/927-8000 | Fax: 317/920-4789 | Contact SPJ Headquarters | Employment Opportunities